11.04.2022

Pet Ethics: Sterilization and Euthanasia

 AGENDA

  1. Friends or family--some of both?
  2. Treatment question: should we sterilize our pets?
  3. Leo Tolstoy, "Strider: The Story of a Horse" (1886) -- Why read a short story? 
  4. Who is Tolstoy?
  5. The story and what it says about animals
  6. Is the message "actionable"?


Empathy--getting inside the minds of animals
  1. Frans De Waal -- by doing careful studies and avoiding anthropodenial/anthropomorphism
  2. Temple Grandin -- through animal science and based on vantage point of being autistic
  3. Lori Gruen -- through "entangled empathy" -- says this is the foundation of ethics
  4. Leo Tolstoy -- through art and imagination


Who is Tolstoy? LINK. (1828-1910)
  • many themes in story, but...
  • he had a serious interest in the treatment of animals
  • visited a slaughterhouse, became a vegetarian


Strider, annotated LINK
  • we will read passages and discuss what they convey










The story teaches about the plight of animals, but what could we do differently? Do any of these make sense?
  • don't spay/neuter -- it costs the animals a lot 
  • instead of spay/neuter, opt for vasectomy and ovary-sparing hysterectomy, so animals retain natural hormones
  • don't breed animals based on superficial characteristics -- don't be a "looksist" -- Westminster Dog Show
  • don't breed animals  at all -- "pedigreeism" is bad
  • stop treating animals as property