Search This Blog

ARSMU.BLOGSPOT.COM

This is the class blog for Phil 3377, Animal Rights, at SMU. Visit often to find material presented during class, including lecture notes, visuals, links to videos, etc.

11.13.2026

Editing wildlife

Kyle Johannsen, "Humanitarian assistance for wild animals" and Wild Animal Ethics, chapter 5. Also interview.


STEP 1: There is vast wild animal suffering 
  • various ways to resist, which we discussed Wed
STEP 2: We should be hands on when it comes to wild animal suffering (like Nussbaum argues), not hands off (like D&K argue) 

STEP 3: Gene drives could be used to reduce  the 'vast wild animal suffering" 

STEP 4: Gene drives would be preferable to conventional wildlife management 

STEP 5: The experimentation involved could be justified

STEP 6: specific gene drives to be explored

 _________________________




STEP 3: Gene drives could be used to reduce the 'vast wild animal suffering" 

  

  • Note that gene drives only work with fast-reproducing animals
  • Not effective for slow-reproducing large mammals (elephants, whales, humans)

Gene drives with business benefits
Gene drives that are good for animals

_________________________


STEP 4: Gene drives vs. conventional wildlife management


"The main reason gene drives are preferable to conventional wildlife management is because the harms of gene drives are initial, rather than perpetual, and because those harms are inflicted on only a small subset of each target population, rather than the entire population." (p. 5)

  • Gene drive finishes pretty fast, then animals have liberty
  • Fences and nets (Nussbaum) restrict liberty
  • Culling animals  (next week) -- mass death

_________________________

STEP 5: The experimentation involved could be justified

  • he thinks animals have rights, but they are prima facie, not absolute, so they can be overridden
  • experimenting on 100 rabbits to benefit trillions of future rabbits
_________________________

STEP 6: specific gene drives to be explored

  • make certain predatory species sterile so they go extinct, stop harming other animals
    • Pro: helps the prey species
    • Con: diversity is beneficial for wildlife as a whole
  • dull the suffering of animals, but not the sensory pain
    • Pro: makes life easier
    • Con: may be maladaptive, may also deaden pleasure
  • change r-strategists into K-strategists  -- e.g. make rabbits reproduce less, invest more
  • change carnivores into herbivores -- e.g. make coyotes less hungry for rabbits




_________________________


Interview: Johanssen on “bottlenecks” and objections
  1. Survivorship bias -- we think about mature animals, not the vast number of dying juveniles

  2. Underestimation of number of wild animals

  3. "Natural is good"

  4. Conservation -- tendency to focus on healthy ecosystems, restoration, species preservation--NOT individual animal welfare