Search This Blog

ARSMU.BLOGSPOT.COM

This is the class blog for Phil 3377, Animal Rights, at SMU. Visit often to find material presented during class, including lecture notes, visuals, links to videos, etc.

Exam 2 Study Guide

 Basics

  • Exam 2 is on Nov 4. We will review on Nov 2.
  • It's worth 30% of your grade. 
  • The exam will consist of 4-5 questions and you will have some choice of which to answer.
  • Each question will have 3 parts
  • You should plan on writing for the whole 50-55 minutes
  • Please do not ask questions during the exam!  They are rarely answerable and are disruptive to other students.

What the questions will be like
  • Question 1: (a) Explain one defense of animals as food. (b) Clarify how this defense is different from one other defense (either from Module 4 or Module 1). (c) Make an objection to this defense.

Study materials:

  • Use the list of posts (with topic highlights) below...follow the links!
  • Use your own notes.
  • Reread articles as needed.
  • Review RR questions and your answers
  • Think about your feedback on Exam 1

_________________________


Highlighted topics were reviewed on 11/2.   They are not the only topics that will be covered on the exam!

Module 3.  Animals and humans: the contemporary debate

9.23 Do animals have moral standing?  Argument from marginal cases (Singer & Regan); Carruthers' contractualism; his conclusions about rational humans, marginal cases, and animals; how he would respond to the argument from marginal cases

9.25 Do animals have moral standing?  Peter Carruthers on why animal cruelty is bad; thought experiments in Carruthers, e.g. Ingrid the Astronaut and Lazy Jane the Doctor

9:28 Political categories: citizens. Donaldson & Kymlicka (D&K)'s parallel between human political categories and animal categories; why think of domesticated animals as citizens?; what are the rights and responsibilities of animal citizens?; access to public spaces and restaurants; non-exploitative and exploitative animal work

9.30 Political categories: wild sovereigns and liminal denizens  D&K on liminal denizens; examples: mice, Canada geese; D&K on wild sovereigns; examples: rutting elk, struggling Eagles at White Rock Lake, icelandic pufflings

10.2 Higher and lower animals  Shelly Kagan's key concepts -- Unitarianism, Deontology, Utilitarianism, Hierarchy;  how to add hierarchy to Utilitarianism; how to add hierarchy to Deontology;  which capacities make a difference to moral status; three troubling implications of the hierarchy view--superior beings, marginal cases, normal variation

10.5 Higher and lower animals  Another crucial Kagan concept -- practical realism; how Kagan uses practical realism in his argument for how many different moral statuses there are; his classification of different species; how Kagan uses practical realism to solve the problems about marginal cases and normal variation; what he says about superior beings; Kagan's animal advocacy


Module 4. Using animals as food

10.7 Using animals as food: factory farming & reformed/humane farming; there is a lot of information here;. You should be able to pick one food and explain three types of animal farming behind it; for example, if the food is turkey, you should be able to explain standard factory farming of turkeys + reformed factory farming of turkeys + humane farming of turkeys; you should also be aware of slaughter issues.

10.9  Arguments for vegetarianism  James Rachels' taste argument; should be able to lay out the main premises; how this argument differs from arguments made by Singer and Regan; you should be able to articulate an objection.

10.14 The causal inefficacy defense  Mark Budolfson's key concepts: efficacy, inefficacy, threshold, essentiality of harm; cases where we have efficacy and lack efficacy; why he thinks Singer's threshold argument is wrong; why we lack efficacy when it comes to FF products; what he means by "slack at each link"; part II of his article--products that are essentially harmful; bottomline: what animal products are ethically permissible according to Budolfson?; you should be able to articulate an objection.

10.16 The humane farming/existence defense  Nick Zangwill's argument that we should eat humanely farmed animals...it's not just permissible but a duty; what he says about the pleasurable lives of humanely farmed animals; what he says about eating dogs and people; you should be able to articulate an objection.

10.19 The freegan defense  Bruckner key concepts: freegan, unnecessary harm, accidental deaths; basic moral principle (it's wrong to cause or support the causing of unnecessary harm); why he thinks omnivores violate this basic moral principle the most; why vegans also violate the principle (because of accidental deaths of field animals);  you should be able to articulate an objection.

10.21 State fair and rodeo  Rollin's admiration for ranchers and cowboys; the rodeo event that concerns him most.

 

Module 5. More uses of animals

10.23 Animal companions  The debate about having pets; Francione and Charlton (F&C) on domesticated animals as pathetic (why?) and extinction as a goal; Donaldson and Kymlicka's alternative view of domesticated animals.

10.26 Outdoor cats, bringing back pets  Abbate key concepts: animal wellbeing, hedonism, physiological and ethological pleasures; infliction and deprivation, prima facie duties; why she thinks cat guardians have a prima facie duty to allow cats outside; why it's just a prima facie duty; what about wild animals who may be killed by outdoor cats?

10.28 Using animals for research Singer's examples of cruel and pointless animal research; examples of seemingly worthwhile research; Singer's position on animal research; brain damated orphans; Utilitarianism; the Animal Welfare Act.

10.30 Using animals for research Engel's commonsense case against animal research; what is the commonsense principle he invokes?; the extrapolation problem; how Carbone responds to arguments like Engel's.