How should we think about the wellbeing of animals living in zoos, aquariums, safari parks?
We already have a lot of tools for thinking about this in our toolbox:
- Sentience (Browning and Birch & Singer) -- Are the animals feeling pleasure? Are they feeling pain?
- Sophisticated hedonism (Abbate) --all pleasure and pain matter, but t's particularly important whether animals are experiencing ethological pleasures -- the pleasures provided by their innate, instinctive behaviors. She talks about the pleasure cats take into marking their territory and hunting. Each animal in a zoo/aquarium has a set of ethological pleasures it's able/not able to experience.
- Capabilities approach (Nussbaum)--there are 10 different capabilities that animals would be able to achieve in a just world.
- Animals in the wild -- Johanssen argues that animals have pretty bad lives in the wild, especially (but not only) if they are r-strategists and if they live in an environment that includes predators. If you agree with him about animals in the wild, you might look more favorably upon zoos and aquariums, where animals live longer lives and aren't vulnerable to predators.
_________________________
Now we'll add more tools....
Lori Gruen, "Dilemmas of Captivity"--from Ethics and Animals: An Introduction
Judging zoos, aquariums, etc.
- Are they good or bad for the individual wild animals who live there?
- Are they beneficial for wild animals still in the wild? Do they foster conservation effectively?
| Question 1: Are they OK? |
Gruen: captivity is generally bad for captive wild animals for two reasons--
- Loss of liberty
- Loss of wild dignity
Gruen's points about liberty
- Liberty is instrumentally good for wild animals
- in captivity they usually have unmet needs
- example: birds in aviary can't fly; zugunruhe
- next time: your observations
- Liberty is intrinsically good for animals--constitutive of their wellbeing
- however well off an animal is, they'd be better off if they freely met their own needs
Gruen's points about wild dignity

Kantian dignity: humans have dignity because they are self-aware, adopt their own goals, and understand right and wrong. Gruen: no application to animals.Political dignity: humans have dignity to the extent they are recognized as citizens in a society--can speak, assemble, vote, etc. Gruen: no application to animalsAnimal dignity: any being has dignity to the extent it can exercise its species-specific capacities. Wild and domesticated animals can have dignity, potentially. Gruen's doubts: Is every natural animal behavior really dignified?Wild dignity: wild animals have dignity to the extent that they have their own lives, live in their own world, and possess a kind of sovereignty. Captivity deprives wild animals of this sort of wild dignity. Gruen: this is the right concept for wild animals, but has no application to domesticated animals.
_________________________
interlude: dignity and domesticated animals
![]() |
| dogs with bread faces (this is a thing) |
Gruen: No loss of wild dignity (dogs can have none), but treated as objects
_________________________
Animal sanctuaries
- for chimpanzees retired from animal labs - Chimp Haven
- for elephants who didn't thrive in zoos - The Elephant Sanctuary
- for wild animals who didn't work out as pets
- for rescued dogs, cats, farm animals (domesticated)
What does Gruen say about animal sanctuaries?
_________________________
After captivity, can wild animals be returned to the wild?

