Culling vs. hunting
- US Fish and Wildlife Service plans to cull a half million "invasive" barred owls in the Pacific Northwest over the next 30 years, to protect endangered spotted owls -- article (2024)
- Cahoone's defense of hunting doesn't apply to culling barred owls
- Not hunting because not an "archaic trophic activity"
- his reasoning about hunting doesn't apply (no extra harm analysis, benefits)
- Doesn't mean Cahoone is opposed...it's just another subject, not what his article is about
_________________________
Culling case study -- culling buffalo in Yellowstone National Park -- Mass Yellowstone Hunt Kills 1,150 Buffalo
- Bison ecology (video)
- Bison management (National Park explanation)
- in winter buffalo migrate to lower elevations outside the park boundaries
- could mix with livestock, brucellosis issue (contested)
- herd size, absence of predators -- wolves can kill buffalo, but rarely do
![]() |
| NYT |
- For them, an "archaic trophic activity" (in Cahoone's sense)
- Some buffalo also transferred to reservations
Native American involvement in opposing culling
Our question: Is it ethical to slaughter buffalo when they migrate to lower altitudes in the winter?
_________________________
Donaldson & Kymlicka's framework (Zoopolis, chapter 6 "Wild Sovereignty")
- wild animals parallel foreign nationals,
- we should respect their ways, "hands off"
Homelands, territory
- foreign nationals have a homeland
- there should be homelands for wild animals
- a mix of species will share a homeland
- homelands can overlap -- animal homeland doesn't have to exclude humans
- compare: Indian reservations that don't exclude non-tribe members
Upshot for the culling issue
- Yellowstone is a "homeland" for buffalo and the other species who live there
- D&K might say: buffalo homeland should be sufficient to accommodate their natural behavior
_________________________
Other implications of treating Yellowstone as animal homeland
- priority for animals, not tourists -- e.g speed limits
- reduction of tourism?
_________________________
Complexities of animal homelands: migratory animals
- US law does already provide some protection for migratory animals
- Migratory bird treaty act -- special protection these birds carry with them wherever they go -- limitations on hunting
- Endangered migratory animals -- they carry special protection wherever they go
- Shipping speed limits to protect migrating whales
- but there could be more wildlife corridors -- protection of migratory routes from development





