Search This Blog

ARSMU.BLOGSPOT.COM

This is the class blog for Phil 3377, Animal Rights, at SMU. Visit often to find material presented during class, including lecture notes, visuals, links to videos, etc.

11.17.2026

"Cull of the Wild"

Culling vs. hunting

  • US Fish and Wildlife Service plans to cull a half million "invasive" barred owls in the Pacific Northwest over the next 30 years, to protect endangered spotted owls -- article (2024)


  • Cahoone's defense of hunting doesn't apply to culling barred owls
    • Not hunting because not an "archaic trophic activity"
    • his reasoning about hunting doesn't apply (no extra harm analysis, benefits)
  • Doesn't mean Cahoone is opposed...it's just another subject, not what his article is about

_________________________



Culling case study -- culling buffalo in Yellowstone National Park -- Mass Yellowstone Hunt Kills 1,150 Buffalo


Why cull?

  • in winter buffalo migrate to lower elevations outside the park boundaries
  • could mix with livestock, brucellosis issue (contested)
  • herd size, absence of predators -- wolves can kill buffalo, but rarely do
Native American involvement with culling

NYT

  • For them, an "archaic trophic activity" (in Cahoone's sense)
  • Some buffalo also transferred to reservations
Native American involvement in opposing culling

Our question: Is it ethical to slaughter buffalo when they migrate to lower altitudes in the winter?

_________________________

Donaldson & Kymlicka's framework (Zoopolis, chapter 6 "Wild Sovereignty")
  • wild animals parallel foreign nationals,
  • we should respect their ways, "hands off"
Homelands, territory
  • foreign nationals have a homeland
  • there should be homelands for wild animals
  • a mix of species will share a homeland
  • homelands can overlap -- animal homeland doesn't have to exclude humans
  • compare: Indian reservations that don't exclude non-tribe members
Upshot for the culling issue
  • Yellowstone is a "homeland" for buffalo and the other species who live there
  • D&K might say: buffalo homeland should be sufficient to accommodate their natural behavior
_________________________


Other implications of treating Yellowstone as animal homeland
_________________________


Complexities of animal homelands: migratory animals

  • but there could be more wildlife corridors -- protection of migratory routes from development