Search This Blog

ARSMU.BLOGSPOT.COM

This is the class blog for Phil 3377, Animal Rights, at SMU. Visit often to find material presented during class, including lecture notes, visuals, links to videos, etc.

11.20.2026

Animals in captivity

No office hours today

No class Monday 

Happy Thanksgiving!

_________________________


How should we think about the wellbeing of animals living in zoos, aquariums, safari parks?

We already have a lot of tools for thinking about this in our toolbox:


  1. Sentience (Browning and Birch & Singer) -- Are the animals feeling pleasure? Are they feeling pain?
  2. Sophisticated hedonism (Abbate) --all pleasure and pain matter, but t's particularly important whether animals are experiencing ethological pleasures -- the pleasures provided by their innate, instinctive behaviors.  She talks about the pleasure cats take into marking their territory and hunting.  Each animal in a zoo/aquarium has a set of ethological pleasures it's able/not able to experience.
  3. Capabilities approach (Nussbaum)--there are 10 different capabilities that animals would be able to achieve in a just world.
  4. Animals in the wild -- Johanssen argues that animals have pretty bad lives in the wild, especially (but not only) if they are r-strategists and if they live in an environment that includes predators. If you agree with him about animals in the wild, you might look more favorably upon zoos and aquariums, where animals live longer lives and aren't vulnerable to predators.

_________________________

Now we'll add more tools....

Lori Gruen, "Dilemmas of Captivity"--from Ethics and Animals: An Introduction

Judging zoos, aquariums, etc.

  1. Are they good or bad for the individual wild animals who live there? 
  2. Are they beneficial for wild animals still in the wild?  Do they foster conservation effectively?
Question 1: Are they OK?

Question 2: Because of zoos, are they better off?

Gruen: captivity is generally bad for captive wild animals for two reasons--

  1. Loss of liberty
  2. Loss of wild dignity

Gruen's points about liberty

  1. Liberty is instrumentally good for wild animals
    • in captivity they usually have unmet needs
    • example: birds in aviary can't fly; zugunruhe
    • next time: your observations
  2. Liberty is intrinsically good for animals--constitutive of their wellbeing
    • however well off an animal is, they'd be better off if they freely met their own needs


Gruen's points about wild dignity




Kantian dignity: humans have dignity because they are self-aware, adopt their own goals, and understand right and wrong.  Gruen: no application to animals.

Political dignity: humans have dignity to the extent they are recognized as citizens in a society--can speak, assemble, vote, etc.  Gruen: no application to animals

Animal dignity: any being has dignity to the extent it can exercise its species-specific capacities. Wild and domesticated animals can have dignity, potentially. Gruen's doubts: Is every natural animal behavior really dignified?

Wild dignity: wild animals have dignity to the extent that they have their own lives, live in their own world, and possess a kind of sovereignty.  Captivity deprives wild animals of this sort of wild dignity. Gruen: this is the right concept for wild animals, but has no application to domesticated animals.

_________________________

interlude: dignity and domesticated animals

dogs with bread faces (this is a thing)

Gruen: No loss of wild dignity (dogs can have none), but treated as objects

_________________________

Field trips --
  • How do the animals seem to be doing at the zoo, aquarium, wildlife park you visited?
  • Does Gruen's critique apply -- do the animals have a troubling lack of liberty or wild dignity?
  • Did you think about the animals using any of the other tools?

________________________


Animal sanctuaries
  • for chimpanzees retired from animal labs - Chimp Haven
  • for elephants who didn't thrive in zoos - The Elephant Sanctuary
  • for wild animals who didn't work out as pets
  • for rescued dogs, cats, farm animals (domesticated)
What does Gruen say about animal sanctuaries?

_________________________

After captivity, can wild animals be returned to the wild?

11.17.2026

"Cull of the Wild"

Culling vs. hunting

  • US Fish and Wildlife Service plans to cull a half million "invasive" barred owls in the Pacific Northwest over the next 30 years, to protect endangered spotted owls -- article (2024)


  • Cahoone's defense of hunting doesn't apply to culling barred owls
    • Not hunting because not an "archaic trophic activity"
    • his reasoning about hunting doesn't apply (no extra harm analysis, benefits)
  • Doesn't mean Cahoone is opposed...it's just another subject, not what his article is about

_________________________



Culling case study -- culling buffalo in Yellowstone National Park -- Mass Yellowstone Hunt Kills 1,150 Buffalo


Why cull?

  • in winter buffalo migrate to lower elevations outside the park boundaries
  • could mix with livestock, brucellosis issue (contested)
  • herd size, absence of predators -- wolves can kill buffalo, but rarely do
Native American involvement with culling

NYT

  • For them, an "archaic trophic activity" (in Cahoone's sense)
  • Some buffalo also transferred to reservations
Native American involvement in opposing culling

Our question: Is it ethical to slaughter buffalo when they migrate to lower altitudes in the winter?

_________________________

Donaldson & Kymlicka's framework (Zoopolis, chapter 6 "Wild Sovereignty")
  • wild animals parallel foreign nationals,
  • we should respect their ways, "hands off"
Homelands, territory
  • foreign nationals have a homeland
  • there should be homelands for wild animals
  • a mix of species will share a homeland
  • homelands can overlap -- animal homeland doesn't have to exclude humans
  • compare: Indian reservations that don't exclude non-tribe members
Upshot for the culling issue
  • Yellowstone is a "homeland" for buffalo and the other species who live there
  • D&K might say: buffalo homeland should be sufficient to accommodate their natural behavior
_________________________


Other implications of treating Yellowstone as animal homeland
_________________________


Complexities of animal homelands: migratory animals

  • but there could be more wildlife corridors -- protection of migratory routes from development





    11.16.2026

    Hunting ethics

    Next time: culling animals as a form of wildlife management ... specific example from Yellowstone

    _________________________

     Laurence Cahoone, "Hunting as a Moral Good"

    Is hunting ethical?

    _________________________

    What our authors say or would say about hunting...

    BIBLE, Genesis 9

    ARISTOTLE, Politics Book I, ch. 8

    KANT, Lectures on Ethics

    CARRUTHERS, "Against the moral standing of animals"


    SINGER, REGAN, D&K

    _________________________


    Defending hunting: Cahoone
    1. What is Cahoone's defense of hunting?
    2. Is it too permissive? (too positive about hunting)
    3. Is it too restrictive? (rules out too many forms of hunting)

    Field trips

    _________________________

    Cahoone ....
    • Assumes: individual animals do matter, do have moral standing
      • Peter Singer: utilitarian view
      • Tom Regan: rights view
      • Environmental holism: individuals matter, but the whole ecosystem matters more
    • proposes a "meliorist principle"--a meliorist is someone who thinks we can make a better place; a reformer or crusader
    meliorist principle: "humanly caused animal death and suffering should be reduced as much as possible, hence allowed only if necessary. 'Necessary' must refer to goods of ecosystems, or human goods or rights, sufficient to justify the animal death or harm." (Cahoone p. 495)
    •  Cahoone's goal: show that enough good can come of hunting to justify the death and harm to animals, even if animals do have moral status
    _________________________

    STEP 1: What is hunting?

    1. the sport of killing animals--for fun or challenge. (Cahoone: No!)
    2. p. 496 -- not a sport, but a "cultural trophic practice"..."a practical approximation of an archaic activity"  -- like gardening, woodworking, baking bread, knitting
    Examples:
    1. Example of genuine hunting:  deer hunting (for venison)
    2. Not hunting at all: trophy hunting, other
    Cahoone: trophy hunting isn't hunting!


    _________________________

    Contemporary hunting background (p. 496)
    1. Hunting seasons, permits, bag limits
    2. Weapons used
    3. "Hunting ethics" (p. 498) -- death should be quick; no mere wounding; preservation of species; safety for humans; fair chase; animal is used as food; a form of wildlife management


    _________________________

    STEP 2: Justifying hunting

    It's defensible for hunters to cause death and harm if/when...
    1. animal eaten, not wasted (p. 498)
    2. animal killed, not just wounded, and killed quickly (p. 497)
    3. death by hunter causes no extra suffering
      • compared to imminent wild death (p. 499)
      • compared to what animals suffer in animal agriculture [or commercial fishing] (p. 499)
      • compared to what animals suffer due to plant farming (p. 499)
        • Note: How much do animals suffer due to plant farming?  Also discussed by Bruckner.  The claim that they suffer just as much in plant farming is controversial.  See this article by Andy Lamey.
    So far Cahoone's argument is only that the death and harm caused by hunting can be justified. Now he makes the case that hunting is positively good.

    Positive benefits of hunting
    1. hunter embodies "anachronistic self sufficiency" (p. 501) ... like wood-workers, knitters, etc.
    2. hunter manifests "trophic responsibility" -- they "face their food" (p. 501)
    3. hunters possess "ecological expertise" (p. 501)
    4. hunter recognizes place in nature relative to animals, feels respect and gratitude (p. 501)
    5. hunter "does not add to but replaces some part of the massive, anonymous animal suffering caused by unseen consumers, omnivores, and vegetarians, with pain caused personally and directly, in which the anmal's life and death are intimately recognized and responsibility taken." (p. 502)
    6. "hunter allows the animal its wild life" .(p. 502)

    _________________________


    Field trips

    _________________________


    Assessment:  Did Cahoone satisfy his own meliorist principle?

    meliorist principle: "humanly caused animal death and suffering should be reduced as much as possible, hence allowed only if necessary. 'Necessary' must refer to goods of ecosystems, or human goods or rights, sufficient to justify the animal death or harm." (Cahoone p. 495)

    _________________________


    Other types of hunting
    1. 777 ranch
    2. African safari hunting  ... not actually hunting by Cahoone's definition
    Cahoone's defense does not apply.  Do any other defenses apply?

    11.13.2026

    Editing wildlife

    Kyle Johannsen, "Humanitarian assistance for wild animals" and Wild Animal Ethics, chapter 5. Also interview.


    STEP 1: There is vast wild animal suffering 
    • various ways to resist, which we discussed Wed
    STEP 2: We should be hands on when it comes to wild animal suffering (like Nussbaum argues), not hands off (like D&K argue) 

    STEP 3: Gene drives could be used to reduce  the 'vast wild animal suffering" 

    STEP 4: Gene drives would be preferable to conventional wildlife management 

    STEP 5: The experimentation involved could be justified

    STEP 6: specific gene drives to be explored

     _________________________




    STEP 3: Gene drives could be used to reduce the 'vast wild animal suffering" 

      

    • Note that gene drives only work with fast-reproducing animals
    • Not effective for slow-reproducing large mammals (elephants, whales, humans)

    Gene drives with business benefits
    Gene drives that are good for animals

    _________________________


    STEP 4: Gene drives vs. conventional wildlife management


    "The main reason gene drives are preferable to conventional wildlife management is because the harms of gene drives are initial, rather than perpetual, and because those harms are inflicted on only a small subset of each target population, rather than the entire population." (p. 5)

    • Gene drive finishes pretty fast, then animals have liberty
    • Fences and nets (Nussbaum) restrict liberty
    • Culling animals  (next week) -- mass death

    _________________________

    STEP 5: The experimentation involved could be justified

    • he thinks animals have rights, but they are prima facie, not absolute, so they can be overridden
    • experimenting on 100 rabbits to benefit trillions of future rabbits
    _________________________

    STEP 6: specific gene drives to be explored

    • make certain predatory species sterile so they go extinct, stop harming other animals
      • Pro: helps the prey species
      • Con: diversity is beneficial for wildlife as a whole
    • dull the suffering of animals, but not the sensory pain
      • Pro: makes life easier
      • Con: may be maladaptive, may also deaden pleasure
    • change r-strategists into K-strategists  -- e.g. make rabbits reproduce less, invest more
    • change carnivores into herbivores -- e.g. make coyotes less hungry for rabbits




    _________________________


    Interview: Johanssen on “bottlenecks” and objections
    1. Survivorship bias -- we think about mature animals, not the vast number of dying juveniles

    2. Underestimation of number of wild animals

    3. "Natural is good"

    4. Conservation -- tendency to focus on healthy ecosystems, restoration, species preservation--NOT individual animal welfare




    11.11.2026

    Life in the wild

    Misc

    • Field trips
    • will return exams today




    Kyle Johansson, "Humanitarian Assistance for Wild Animals"

    Major claims in this article--

    (1) - (6): wild animals have bad lives
    (7) - (11): what we should do about it

    We will discuss (1) - (6) today



    (1) Humanitarian assistance -- does not mean rescuing koala bears from bush fires or saving raccoons and deer after a hurricane. 

    "Severe suffering is pervasive in nature. It's built into natural proccesses, and thus it's the norm rather than the exception." (p. 33)


    (2) Evolution isn't necessarily beneficial to individual animals -- it's beneficial to their genes 

    • peacocks encumbered by their tails
    • male songbirds attract predators



    (3) A common reproductive strategy involves lots of offspring, lots of mortality

    r-strategists--huge number of offspring, little parental investment, most offspring die young
    1. examples of r-strategists that are mammals
    2. huge numbers killed by predators
    K-strategists -- smaller number of offspring, more parental investment, fewer die young (note that a lot do still die young)
    • humans -- 2 per couple, one per partner -- replacement rate
    • eagles -- each female lays 2-3 eggs per year for 20 years
    • leopards--each female leopard has 2-3 cubs every 15 mo-2 years, over 10 years.  
    • puffins--each female puffin has one chick every year over 30 years

    (4) Predation is another cause of wild animal suffering
    1. 2/3 of wild animals eat other animals
    2. Prey die miserable deaths





    (5) Mature wild animals also suffer due to --
    • "disease, parasites, predator-induced stress, predator-caused injuries, and extreme temperatures" (p. 34)
    • He doesn't discuss, but we could also add:  competition within species
      • Male lions, cheetahs, leopards kill cubs
      • Wolf packs--fighting for dominance, only alpha male and female mate
      • Ungulates (antelopes, caribou, etc.) fight mates
      • Seals, baboons

    (6) On the whole ...
    Some ethicists have recently speculated that "the amount of suffering in nature probably exceeds the amount of enjoyment in it. They may or may not be right about that, but at the very least we can say that most individual wild animals live bad lives." (p. 34)
    (7)  Philanthropists tend to overlook wild animal suffering
    • they focus on global poverty
    • they focus on factory farming (Effective Altruism website)
    • but "wild animals are far more numerous" (p. 36)
    (8) One type of large-scale assistance is vaccinating animals

    (9) But genetic intervention would be the most effective intervention
    • change carnivores into herbivores
    • change r-strategists into K-strategists
    • alter r-strategists so offspring don't suffer as much
    (10)  Objections to gene editing are weak
    1. there's nothing especially good about naturalness when it conflicts with wellbeing (p. 36)
    2. gene editing doesn't have to be coercive
    3. studying gene editing will involve some animal experimentation
    (11) For now...
    • we should hold off on gene-editing
    • focus on vaccination programs
    • study and build support for gene editing


    _________________________


    Today let's discuss whether wild animals really do have bad lives

    ANIMAL WELLBEING TOOLKIT
    1. Browning and Birch -- sentience in animals
    2. Zangwill -- we should not forget to focus on animal pleasure (in addition to pain)
    3. Abbate -- sophisticated hedonism -- physiological pleasure and pain matter, but ethological pleasure especially matters (pleasure from innate behaviors)
    4. Nussbaum -- a well-off animal can develop 10 capabilities -- they all matter, not just pleasure/pain
      1. Life
      2. Bodily health
      3. Bodily integrity
      4. Senses, imagination, and thought
      5. Emotions
      6. Practical reason -- making key choices
      7. Affiliation
      8. Other species
      9. Play
      10. Control over one's environment

    LIFE IN THE WILD

     

    RABBITS

    11.09.2026

    Hands off vs. hands on

    Animals "out there"

    So far, focus has been on animals in our homes...in our backyards...in factory farms ... in labs. Now we are talking about animals "out there" in wild places like forests, prairies, oceans, etc.

    1. How should we treat wildlife, generally?  (today)
    2. What are the endemic --built in--problems of wildlife and what should we do about these problems?  (11/11 & 13)
    3. Is hunting ok? (11/16 & 18)
    4. Is captivity in zoos and aquaria ok? (11/20)

    _________________________

    How should we treat wildlife, generally?

    What if wild animals DON'T HAVE moral standing?

    Ecological holism (Aldo Leopold, wildlife managers)
    1. What has moral significance is the whole ecosystem
    2. Individual animals have no moral standing
    3. We should help/hunt depending on what's beneficial for the whole ecosystem
    Example: helping/hunting at  Hagerman Wildlife Refuge 
    • hunting seasons (wild boar, white-tailed deer)
    • crops planted for migratory birds





    _________________________


    Suppose you think that wild animals DO have moral standing.  Should we be...
    1. Hands off approaches to wildlife
    2. Hands on approaches to wildlife (interventionist)

    Hands off 

    Donaldson & Kymlicka: analogy with people in foreign countries



    • No hunting (based on animal rights, not category)
    • If we caused problems, we should help  
    • If problems are endemic, we should respect their "sovereignty"
    • D&K don't rule out one-off rescues; still pretty hands off
    Example: should we build bridges to help the wildebeests crossing the Mara river?



    _________________________



    Hands on approaches

    Martha Nussbaum, Justice for Animals: Our Collective Responsibility

    PART 1: What's wrong with hands off?

    • Hands off intuition involves "romantic dream" (p. 224) about wilderness as better because free of humanity, urban life, industrialization 
    "Oh those animals, so far below us, how alive, how robust they are! If only for a brief five-day safari we could share (from a safe distance) their world of violence and scarcity. Of course, we would never dream of living that life, but we feel a frisson by brief contact, a d we feel more alive. (Many people on eco-safari think and talk in exactly this way.) (p. 236)

    Watching the wildebeeests


     

    • Actual problems of wild animals...
      • starvation
      • weather extremes
      • fires
      • predators
      • high infant mortality
    • The wild doesn't even exist -- every part of nature impacted by humans to some degree
    "However large the tracts of land may be, all land in our world is thoroughly under human control. Thus 'wild animals' in Africa live on animal refuges maintained by the governments of various nations, who control admission to them, defend them from poachers (only sometimes successfully), and support the lives of animals int hem through a range of strategies (including spraying for tsetse tsetse flies and many other matters).  There would be no rhinos or elephants left in the world if humans did not intervene" (p. 228)
      • Lights in cities affect bird migration
      • garbage in oceans and commercial fishing affect sea life
      • climate change affects many species
      • habitat loss affects all species

    _________________________


    PART 2: How to intervene (examples)

    Kyrgyzstan, Ala Archa Park
    1. Zone 1 -- humans may enter for hiking and picnicking
    2. Zone 2 -- wild animals, no humans
    3. Zone 3 -- only breeding animals

    New Zealand bird sanctuary
    • birds evolved without mid-sized mammals, so are defenseless
    • settlers introduced rabbits, squirrels, mice, rabbits
    • sanctuary has netting to keep the mammals out, but give birds freedom
    _________________________

    PART 3:  What is the ultimate goal? When have we acheived justice for animals?
    • rejects the hedonistic Utilitarian's focus on happiness and misery, pleasure and pain
    • all animals should have the opportunity to develop all of their fundamental capabilities
    • What are the central capabilities (Justice for Animals p. 88, 102, 234-235)
      1. Life
      2. Bodily health
      3. Bodily integrity
      4. Senses, imagination, and thought
      5. Emtions
      6. Practical reason -- making key choices
      7. Affiliation
      8. Other species
      9. Play
      10. Control over one's environment
    _________________________

    Peter Singer: Hands off or Hands on?


    11.06.2026

    Helping wild animals

    MODULE 6: WILD ANIMALS



    OUR QUESTIONS IN THIS MODULE
    1. How are wild animals doing out there? Do they live good lives?
    2. What should we do for wild animals? Should we just leave them alone? (first)
    3. Is it ok to hunt wild animals? For sport? For food? For ecological reasons?
    4. Is it ok to capture wild animals and put them in zoos and aquaria?

    _________________________ 


    WHAT SHOULD WE DO FOR WILD ANIMALS?
    • Clare Palmer, "Animal Ethics" 
    • Surveys many ideas we've encountered, but with a focus on wild animals

    SUPPOSE A CAT IS HUNGRY
    • the cat could be in one of these four categories



    CAPACITY VIEW
    • four cats have the same inner capacities; they're all hungry
    • the differences don't matter (why are they vulnerable, who made them vulnerable?) 
    • example: Peter Singer, Utilitarianism; Tom Regan
    CONTEXT VIEW
    • four cats have the same inner capacities; they're all hungry
    • BUT the contexts are different
    • A, B, C: we have special obligations, based on our past role 
      • obligations to not harm
      • obligations to help
    • D: no obligations
    • example: Palmer, D&K
    TODAY: CONTEXT VIEW

    _________________________


    CONTEXT VIEW, APPLIED TO VARIOUS CASES


    Type A: dog you have adopted, tethered outside in winter




    Type C: wild animal made vulnerable by human captivity





    Type C: polar bears unable to hunt on ice due to human-caused climate change





    Type D: mute swans on Lake Ontario, problems not due to humans







    Type D: Hungry white-tailed deer in winter, problems not caused by humans




    _________________________


    CONTEXT VIEW SAYS
    • A, B, C situations: problems are partly human-caused, so we have obligations
    • D situation: problems not human-caused, so no obligation to help
    TWO INTERPRETATIONS OF "NO OBLIGATION TO HELP"
    1. In type D situations, it's not obligatory to help, but also not wrong -- optional
    2. In type D situations, it's not obligatory to help, and in fact it's wrong -- against intervention
    IS INTERVENTION OPTIONAL OR WRONG?

    _________________________


    TYPE D: WILDEBEESTS CROSSING MARA RIVER (TANZANIA)
    • they migrate to mating grounds and birthing grounds
    • some fall to their deaths or drown or are killed by lions

    wildebeests crossing the Mara river in Tanzania
    Wildebeest safari website


    BUILDING A BRIDGE TO HELP THESE ANIMALS... OPTIONAL OR WRONG?

    WILDLIFE BRIDGE

    Washington State
    a wildlife bridge in a type C situation


    _________________________


    ANOTHER TYPE D

    Leopard infanticide in the Okavanga Delta, Botswana
    1. PBS: Big Cats
    2. Xudum is the mother, Musweu is the male intruder
    3. Film-makers are Brad and Tristan
    SCARING INTRUDER AWAY: OPTIONAL OR WRONG?



    _________________________


    WHY BE AN ANTI-INTERVENTIONIST?
    • wildness is inherently good
    • whatever is natural is good
    • other species are like sovereign nations--their ways are owed respect (D&K)
    _________________________


    Next author: Martha Nussbaum
    1. Makes a case against this anti-interventionist position
    2. She's PRO intervention



    11.02.2026

    Review for Exam 2

     Groups -- please come up with some topics/questions using the workbook

    _________________________

    Author names -- the exam will jog your memory by supplying article/book titles or concepts along with author names.  

    Choice -- 5 questions, you will answer 4 -- there's a bit of choice within questions as well.

    _________________________

    Cover enough but not too much, plan ahead. For example:

    Explaining arguments 

    1. Make sure your explanation includes key premises -- James Rachels' argument for vegetarianism 
    2. Make sure your explanation doesn't omit crucial ideas -- Bruckner roadkill argument
    Making objections
    • Key thing is to show thoughtfulness, not to make a devastating objection -- Bruckner objections
    Defining terms
    • Any unfamiliar terms should be defined--e.g. marginal casees, superior beings, ethological pleasures, etc.
    Giving examples
    • To make yourself clear, it's always good to give examples.  For example (!), say you're saying that D&K think animal citizens have a responsibility to do non-exploitative work.  What's an example of non-exploitative work?


    10.30.2026

    Animal Research

    Review Monday, study guide at tab

    _________________________

    How to take a position on animal research


    _________________________


    Tom Regan's position: no animal research
    • "In the case of animals used in science the rights view is categorically abolitionist. Lab animals are not our tasters, we are not their kings." (Regan, "The Case for Animal Rights" p. 9)



    Peter Singer's position: rarely ethical


    • Tipu Aziz -- 100 monkeys used to test deep brain stimulation that helped 40,000 Parkinson's patients (ALN p. 21)
    • but also right to do this research on comparable humans
    _________________________


    Mylan Engel's position: stop all animal research, but proceeds from commonsense ethics

    "The Commonsense Case Against Animal Experimentation"

    • Note: paper seems to take a position on all animal experimentation but he focusses on the first--
      • drug testing
      • vaccine testing
      • basic anatomy and physiology
      • causes and progression of diseases 
      • develop surgical procedures
      • psychology research
      • etc.
    • Starts from obvious ethics, makees non-obvious factual claims

    _________________________


    Engel's factual claims about animal research

    Drug testing background:  testing covid vaccines on monkeys



    The Extrapolation problem
    • Dogs and chocolate
    • LD50 test -- stands for "lethal dose 50%" -- the amount of a substance that causes death in 50% when given to a set of animals
      • "Why should anyone care how much of X proves lethal to 50 percent of rat subjects? This idiosyncratic information has no relevance to human health and well being It is no more useful than knowing whether the number of blades of grass in your front yard is odd or even." (Engel p. 220)
      • example of a use -- testing the strength of batches of botox using LD50 on mice
    • drug testing failures

    • Learning from research vs. luck
      • Covid vaccine safe and effective in monkeys ... safe and effective in humans ... just luck
      • Aziz brain stimulation method safe and effective in monkeys...safe and effective in humans ... just luck

    If we stopped animal research, are there alternatives?

    • Use computer models
    • Test on human volunteers, using microdosing
    _________________________

    Larry Carbone 
    • lab vet -- author of The Hidden Lives of Lab Animals   
    • "The Utility of Basic Animal Research" -- we do gain useful information from animal research
    • Veterinarians extrapolate from one species to another all the time
    • evolutionary biology supports extrapolation
    • Biomedical research is probabilistic--doesn't provide certainty
    • There are also failures of extrapolation from other types of research--in vitro, computer models, epidemiology, using human volunteers, etc.

    _________________________

    If Carbone and Singer are right about the utility of SOME animal research, we still have to ask the hard ethical questions
    1. Morally, are we entitled to use animals for human gain?
    2. If we are not entitled, should we stop doing animal research?